Some thoughts on giving written feedback on writing

Kino specializes in the philosophy of statistics and its application in the social sciences. She looks at the methodology of social sciences in general but psychology in particular through the lens of data analysis. Kino posts under the banner "Scattered Plot".
Kino
Latest posts by Kino (see all)

I recently received some unhelpful written feedback. I say “unhelpful” not because the reviewer misinterpreted my writing or didn’t try to help or that I believed my writing was perfect. The feedback was just written in a way that didn’t help me. For example, one sentence I wrote was ” this view implies that programs…

What you need is not love

Kino specializes in the philosophy of statistics and its application in the social sciences. She looks at the methodology of social sciences in general but psychology in particular through the lens of data analysis. Kino posts under the banner "Scattered Plot".
Kino
Latest posts by Kino (see all)

I’m in that awkward career stage where, on the one hand, I’m a senior grad student whom people go to for emotional (and sometimes logistical) support when things don’t work out the way they should, usually related to something a faculty member has done or didn’t do; on the other hand, I’m on the market,…

My proudly average movement

Kino specializes in the philosophy of statistics and its application in the social sciences. She looks at the methodology of social sciences in general but psychology in particular through the lens of data analysis. Kino posts under the banner "Scattered Plot".
Kino
Latest posts by Kino (see all)

Abe is 6 years old. Most kids in his grade 1 class can count to 20 but Abe cannot. Therefore Abe will never go to law school because law schools only want top students. Alex is 18 years old. They tried their hand at driving a couple times and almost hit a tree. Therefore Alex…

Some suggestions for inclusive practices

Kino specializes in the philosophy of statistics and its application in the social sciences. She looks at the methodology of social sciences in general but psychology in particular through the lens of data analysis. Kino posts under the banner "Scattered Plot".
Kino
Latest posts by Kino (see all)

I haven’t been writing for a while. A lot has been happening and maybe I’ll write about them later. But right now, I’m trying to get back to writing. I was talking with some people lately about my climate survey. I talked about what surprising things we might learn from something like this (e.g., men…

Ready to Learn

Jessica studies the philosophy of cognitive science.In particular, she is interested in what cognitive science and neuroscience can tell us about visual perception, how we understand mathematics, and how we make moral judgments.Jessica is a guest writer, posting under the banner "Blooming, Buzzing Confusion."
Jessica
Latest posts by Jessica (see all)

I absolutely believe that teachers can and should learn from students. I’ve heard that sentiment expressed often throughout my teaching career and honestly, I never paused to think about it. It seemed uncontroversial, if not obvious, to me. But after some lively pushback and discussion among friends, I think it’s well worth an attempt to…

Not here to learn

Kino specializes in the philosophy of statistics and its application in the social sciences. She looks at the methodology of social sciences in general but psychology in particular through the lens of data analysis. Kino posts under the banner "Scattered Plot".
Kino
Latest posts by Kino (see all)

I found a hilarious article on McSweeney’s making fun of the expression “students teach me as much as I teach them”, which teachers sometimes voice. I followed it up with a comment that I find it weird when teachers or presenters start the class or workshop with something like “I’m here to also learn from…